I have been spending a lot of time working with online video advertising of late and wanted to share some facts. It is an important space, and as most media and marketing people know, a fast growing one. The world of television (content producers and viewers) continues to move rapidly online. And many people are also creating and distributing original video content online (i.e. not from traditional content producers). Annoying Orange anyone? Gary Vaynerchuk and Wine Library TV? The streaming ads are following at a brisk clip.
Here are some interesting facts that came out in an Ad Age report earlier this week:
currently there 178MM online video viewers in U.S. (eMarketer)
Vizu …doing really interesting things with audience research
Here’s where it gets interesting: 2010 was the first year — ever — that cable subscriptions in the U.S. declined. That’s right – they went down. Competition is coming to a TV, computer, tablet or smart phone near you. Cable and the MSO’s are on the run for the first time. Stay tuned…or should I say “stay logged in”?
All three provided a lot of information and — at various moments — insights. In these challenging economic times, there is one silver lining: people are talking more, exchanging ideas actively and trying to figure how to manage “The New Normal”.
FutureVision was by invite-only and produced by Lyris, the technology company I use for email marketing and analytics. The one day session was jam packed with information and insights. Some of the best moments included:
David Daniels of The Relevancy Group revealing some surprising stats, such as 52% of email marketers still do not target their messaging geographically and instead subscribe to the “spray and pray” strategy.
James Meers of the The British Museum Shop describing how his site’s Welcome Program pop-up has grown email registrations by 20%+ in just one year. Excellent presentation and v-e-r-y Brit-ish.
The NY Times Small Business Summit featured some outstanding speakers, the best of which was Jerry Greenfield of Ben and Jerry’s Ice Cream. He regaled the crowd of 800 with the story of how he and Ben Cohen started the company after taking a $5.oo mail-in correspondence course on ice cream making and then somehow got bank financing and rented a former gas station as their first store. The only question afterward was whether such serendipity and luck can occur in today’s business climate. Hmmm. Another high point was a panel that included Paul Downs, founder & CEO of Paul Downs Cabinetmakers. Paul writes a blog for The NY Times about the struggles of a small business trying to survive in a tough economy. It is called Staying Alive. See his posts. He is engaging as a speaker, and his message of survival is topical.
Advertising Week— tag line “Get Out of Your Head” — was a smorgasbord of sessions, speakers, panels and locations. 60,000 advertising professionals from all over the world. Agencies, brands, technology providers — everyone connected with the industry. I didn’t run into a single executive from a traditional media property though. (I find that surprising and little troubling.) The locus of the event was The Times Center, which is where all the sessions I attended took place.
Here are the highlights.
Best presentation: Designing An Agency for the Digital Age – Nick Law Chief Creative Officer and Barry Wacksman , Executive Vice President Chief Growth Officer R/GA. Brilliant and visionary.
Best spontaneous Broadway song during a presentation: Carolyn Everson, Corporate Vice President, Global Sales and Strategy, Microsoft Advertising, who during ‘Pushing Entertainment in the Digital Age’, brought out several Broadway performers who burst into song with an amusing ditty — piano accompaniment, dance steps, harmony and all. She even had a cameo in the can-can line.
Most insightful discussion on the future of agencies: Stop Talking and Start Listening – Tapping Into The Collective Intelligence. This panel featured Brian Collins, Chairman & CCO, COLLINS:, Michael Lebowitz, Founder & CEO, Big Spaceship, Ty Montague, Creative Director, Co. All had valuable perspectives on how the big agency model is being broken down and left behind.
Best quote: “The future is a team sport.” – Ty Montague, regarding crowd-sourcing and the new agency model.
Best (and simplest) Social Media insight: “think about what OBJECTS or PROMOTIONS marketers can deliver to FaceBook that deliver value to the social system and its people…” – David Kirkpatrick, author of The Facebook Effect
Key mobile media insights: (i) by end of 2011 there will be more smart phones that regular mobile phones (ii) by end of 2013 more web access will occur via mobile than via computers
Most interesting factoid: Android will eclipse iPhone by 2012.
Best summation of the advertising industry today: “We are at the beginning of an era where marketing will be more and more DATA DRIVEN and intelligent vs. MASS MEDIA and “scatter shot”. Geico’s marketing is scatter-shot. Amazon’s is targeted and data driven. The question is: how will the distribution mechanisms change.” – Greg Rogers, CEO & Co-Founder, Pictela
Most interesting question posed to an agency panel: “What place does a 50 year old creative director have in today’s agency model?” During Stop Talking and Start Listening.
2nd best quote: “”The purpose of advertising is to help consumers decide”. – Quentin George, Chief Digital Officer, MediaBrands. Simple, but true.
“The Flight To Quality” is an investment term for when investors move their capital away from riskier investments to the safest possible investment vehicles. In The New Normal I write about, I believe we are seeing a flight to quality across a broad spectrum of business: media & marketing, retail, entertainment, sports and more. And I believe it takes the form of a a “Flight To Quality…and VALUE“.
Sometimes it is truly about quality and less about price…Take for example the recent case where a package of bed linens bargain-priced for $35.00 at Kmart sold significantly LESS than a quite similar package at Pottery Barn that was priced at $129.00. Was this because upper middle class shoppers at Pottery Barn are spending more freely in the recession than lower middle class shoppers at Kmart? Maybe — but actually I believe it was because the Pottery Barn product was higher quality, longer lasting and therefore ultimate a better value.
Similarly, look at what has happened to the live entertainment industry in 2010. (See WSJ article.) A shockingly large number of high profile, major tour dates were canceled by some of the world’s best selling music artists: The Eagles, Christina Aguilera, The Dixie Chicks and others. The reason? Low ticket sales. The reasons cited were (i) the artists were touring too much (over-saturating their market) and (ii) they weren’t releasing any new music (no new albums). So the public said: “These tickets are expensive, really. I saw this artist last year, and he/she doesn’t have a new record. It’s not worth it.”
“It’s not worth it.” The attitude and outlook of the New Normal is defined by the question: “Is it worth it?”
In Sports: “Is it worth it to re-up and continue being a season ticket subscriber in the face of my team’s lousy management and escalating ticket prices?” see NY Times piece on personal seat licenses
In Media and Marketing: “Is it worth it to re-up and spend lavishly on traditional (read: expensive) media buys like radio, TV and print? Or should I shift my focus even more to measurable media online and in the mobile space, where I can calculate my ROI?” WSJ 9/23/2010
The margin for error has gotten smaller. And whether you’re buying sheets, tickets or advertising, these days you are going to buy:
what provides the most VALUE
Sometimes it is about lower price, sometimes it’s not. But making sure you get what you want and need has never been more relevant.
Over the past several years I have reflected frequently on where we are in the evolution of media and marketing — with one (1) goal in mind: what is the best way to market and promote a product or service RIGHT NOW. What is the How/What/Where/Who? To answer this question effectively it is helpful to review where we have been over the past 90 years. There have been three main phases:
Media & Marketing 1.0: 1920-1955 (Pre-Television Era)
Media & Marketing 2.0: 1955-2009 (Post-Television Era)
Media & Marketing 3.0: 2009 onward (Post-Digital Era)
In today’s world — the Post Digital Era — traditional mass media are in decline. Just look at the numbers for newspaper, television and radio advertising. New media (web, email, social and mobile) are of course on the rise. Look no further than what major brand marketers and consumers are doing:
In 1999 mainstream media (TV, Print, Radio) captured 98% of all Ford Motor Co’s advertising dollars in North America. Today it captures less than 70%. (source: Ad Age 2009)
Today internet advertising is greater than all broadcast radio ad spending (6% for Radio, 8% Internet) (source: NAB & IAB)
In 1985 there were 2 out-of-home audio choices (terrestrial radio, the Walkman). Today there are at least 5 choices (satellite radio, mp3 players, Internet radio, terrestrial radio, iPhones).
Bottom line: consumers are consuming media in many more ways than they were 10-15 years ago — thanks to the Internet. And within digital media there are dozens of choices for advertisers to make when they decide on how to push out their message. Below are just a few…12 to be exact:
This list is not all encompassing either. There are more areas within digital. The point ultimately is not to get overwhelmed by the plethora of choices but to embrace them…and to find the sweet spot that is Marketing 3.0. The diagram up top is a rough illustration of this. Somewhere between Traditional Media, Internet and Mobile/Guerilla, is the right mix for any marketing campaign. It is a more complicated world now; so the degree to which marketers become skilled “media mixologists” is more important than ever.
Embrace the choices, embrace the mosaic of ways to get the message out. You will be surprised and delighted when your mix hits just the right note.
Over the past 5 years we have moved into a new age for media and marketing. The Internet has surpassed various traditional media in reach and influence. Media has fragmented. And the ‘work’ of marketing has gotten more complex, more comprehensive, more all inclusive. No longer is traditional marketing and planning sufficient. (Perhaps it is for some of the Fortune 500. But all others take note.) If you expect to market a product or service successfully, you must leverage the “mosaic” of tools that exist: web, email, behavioral targeting, social media, street marketing — and traditional media. This is clear to most good marketers today. But it is the COMBO of tactics — the mix, the ‘secret sauce’ — that makes a campaign in this environment successful.
So the posts shared on this blog will aim to take stock, take note and provide analysis on this new paradigm that I call Marketing 2.0.
New brands will emerge. Existing brands will roll up out new campaigns and products. Some will do so exclusively via digital means, some exclusively via traditional marketing. (Here’s a link to an interesting case study of digital-only marketing success.) But the most interesting work will take place in the intersection of old and new tactics. Where the secret sauce separates winners from losers. Where execution and strategy come together.